Who is a better Quarterback Luck Or RG3?
Both good but LUCK is better
RG3 or Colin Kaepernick! Bigger sophomore season disappointment?
Both have been equally disappointing. Fewer people realize just how much Kaepernick's been struggling because of his team's record. Those few who ARE aware give him a pass because of Crabtree's injury. I think RG3 is doing pretty well for himself considering that the Redskins are giving up more points in the first half than almost any team in the league. Washington was in this position last year (4-6 through 10 last year, 3-7 this year) and he was given lots of accolades for leading the team back to win the division. But Kaepernick had higher expectations coming into the year. RG3 was heavily criticized for taking big hits rather than stepping out of bounds. And I never heard anybody ever say that RG3 had a better arm than Kaepernick. Kaepernick was a more disciplined RG3 with a better arm who would be more likely to succeed on the field in the event that the opponent shut down the run. To me, Kaepernick has been much more disappointing than RG3.
QBs - RG III, Wilson, Kapernick, Luck - do they all move their teams to the Playoffs this coming season?
Kaepernick 99% he will. He's talented and on the best roster ever possibly. Wilson 70% he will. There are many threats to take their wild card spot, and they have some suspensions for key players. Luck 60% he will. There are some other threats for the Colts to take their wild card spot, but he should make it again. RG3 35% he will. He's in a tough division and their defense is in trouble.
Who will be the starting QB's next year for every NFL football team?
I'll even give you a reason! PATRIOTS-Tom Brady (Obviously) JETS-Mark Sanchez (Garrard is a useful back up) BILLS-Kevin Kolb (they didn't sign him to sit on the bench) DOLPHINS-Ryan Tannehill (entering his 2nd year,1st rounder) STEELERS-Ben Roethlisberger (He can lead them to the playoffs) RAVENS-Joe Flacco (Just won a super bowl for them and got a huge contract) BENGALS-Andy Dalton (Solid qb,still under his rookie contract) BROWNS- ???? ...............jk,um.....Brandon Weeden (Colt McCoy has been traded to the 49ers,everyone else sucks and Weeden is already 29 years old! <----so play him ! BRONCOS-Peyton Manning (duh,it's not like they're gonna play John Elway!) CHARGERS-Phillip Rivers ( He's the best they got) CHIEFS-Um.....Alex Smith! (The team already announced he'll be starting next fall) RAIDERS-Geno Smith (They draft Geno Smith cause Palmer sucks and......so does everyone else) COLTS-Andrew Luck (Great Rookie season last year,sometimes to win you need a little LUCK! TEXANS-Matt Schaub (Breaking them records!......Not) JAGUARS-smh probably.....Matt barkley (Draft him and screw everyone else,how many more chances is Blaine Gabbert going to get?) TITANS-Jake Locker (Don't expect him to be a starter for long,titans will draft a qb!) COWBOYS-Tony Romo (Got that big contract,and don't say he doesn't deserve it) EAGLES-Michael Vick (This is tricky cause the house is full of qb's,Vick will start though) GIANTS-Eli Manning (Idk,probably cause he's Peyton's younger brother) REDSKINS-RG3 (No Comment) PACKERS-Aaron Rodgers (Case Closed!!!) LIONS-Matthew Stafford (duh) BEARS-Jay Cutler (Even though he'll get sacked!) VIKINGS-Christian Ponder (Still developing,he'll get there) SAINTS-Drew Brees (Keep breaking records) BUCCANEERS-Josh Freeman (He's alright I guess) PANTHERS-Cam Newton (Heisman Winner,Rookie sensation,etc.) FALCONS-Matt Ryan (Playoff Performer) RAMS-Sam Bradford (He better not get hurt) 49ERS-Colin Kaepernick (Read-Option) SEAHAWKS-Russell Wilson (Great Rookie Year) CARDINALS- Carson Palmer (They trade for him so he can go back to Heisman form)
Do rookie NFL quarterbacks benefit from sitting behind an experienced QB for a time?
Not any more, assuming they were drafted with the intention of having them start in the first place.They used to. Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Carson Palmer, Philip Rivers - lots of early round quarterbacks have spent a year on the bench behind a veteran, learning, and gone on to have great careers.But no player drafted in the first 2 rounds since 2006 who didn’t start a game in his rookie season has gone on to be a franchise quarterback. The only two who have started 48 games are Colin Kaepernick and Chad Henne. Henne would have started as a rookie if the Dolphins hadn’t gotten Chad Pennington late in the offseason. Kaepernick is a more interesting case - he was drafted as a developmental QB, not really intended to start until at least his third or fourth year, but showed enough to make up for his shortcomings when Alex Smith went down.The current rules don’t allow enough practice snaps for quarterbacks to develop off the field. They’re either good enough right out of the box, and able to learn by playing in games, or they aren’t. Maybe just good enough, but there’s enough there to let them continue starting. They may get better, but they won’t become anything much different than what they were when drafted. Kaepernick’s biggest problem is he never got to the next level, never developed into a guy who can run an aggressive NFL style offense under most systems (Seattle is a likely exception, and they are the only team that’s pursuing him) - even as the starter there was never time for that to happen.There’s a lot of talk about changing the practice rules under the next CBA, which would change this situation. I don’t know if it will happen, injuries are still the biggest concern for both coaches and players and more snaps means more chances for a player to get hurt.